Insurance

  • No Insurance Package
  • Premier Protection

Rental Company

  • Budget
  • Avis
  • Dollar
  • National
  • Hertz
  • Thrifty

In total, 94 packages are found for car hire from JFK Airport to Indianapolis Airport, including 20 car models and 6 car hire suppliers. Be noted that the quotes have included a one-way fee already. We’ve found some car hire suppliers’ quotes for the car. Please be aware that the quotes are changing constantly from each supplier. You will need to start a new search and get the instant quote when you are about to book a rental car.

Ford Fiesta
Economy

Ford Fiesta

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
3 suppliers 6 deals
From US$ 210.44 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 210.44 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 219.40 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 210.44 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 219.40 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 569.60 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 578.56 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Ford Focus
Compact

Ford Focus

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
2 suppliers 4 deals
From US$ 213.13 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 213.13 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 222.09 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 213.13 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 222.09 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Hyundai Elantra
Intermediate

Hyundai Elantra

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
3 suppliers 6 deals
From US$ 214.47 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 214.47 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 223.43 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 250.06 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 259.02 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 567.47 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 576.43 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Dodge Avenger
Intermediate

Dodge Avenger

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
1 supplier 2 deals
From US$ 214.47 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 214.47 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 223.43 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Chevrolet Cruze
Intermediate

Chevrolet Cruze

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
1 supplier 2 deals
From US$ 215.81 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 215.81 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 224.77 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Volkswagen Jetta
Standard

Volkswagen Jetta

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
6 suppliers 12 deals
From US$ 217.15 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 217.15 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 226.11 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 217.15 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 226.11 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 251.65 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 260.61 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 562.61 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 571.57 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 563.82 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 572.78 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 805.06 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 814.02 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Chrysler 200
Intermediate

Chrysler 200

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
2 suppliers 4 deals
From US$ 217.15 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 217.15 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 227.15 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 400.27 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 410.27 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Toyota Prius Hybrid
Intermediate

Toyota Prius Hybrid

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
1 supplier 2 deals
From US$ 218.49 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 218.49 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 227.45 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Ford Mustang
Premium

Ford Mustang

  • 4
  • 1
  • 2
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
1 supplier 2 deals
From US$ 218.49 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 218.49 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 228.49 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Ford Fusion
Intermediate

Ford Fusion

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
3 suppliers 6 deals
From US$ 218.49 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 218.49 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 228.49 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 261.15 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 271.15 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 400.27 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 410.27 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Chevrolet Malibu
Full Size

Chevrolet Malibu

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
4 suppliers 8 deals
From US$ 225.21 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 225.21 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 235.21 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 400.27 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 410.27 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 565.43 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 575.43 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 566.48 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 576.48 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Chevrolet Impala
Intermediate

Chevrolet Impala

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
3 suppliers 6 deals
From US$ 229.24 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 229.24 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 239.24 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 261.48 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 271.48 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 580.22 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 590.22 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Ford Escape
Medium SUV

Ford Escape

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
3 suppliers 6 deals
From US$ 229.24 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 229.24 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 239.24 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 261.48 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 271.48 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 567.82 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 577.82 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Ford Edge
Medium SUV

Ford Edge

  • 5
  • 3
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
3 suppliers 6 deals
From US$ 242.67 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 242.67 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 252.67 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 274.91 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 284.91 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 319.72 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 329.72 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Mitsubishi Mirage 2 Doors
Economy

Mitsubishi Mirage 2 Doors

  • 4
  • 1
  • 2
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
1 supplier 2 deals
From US$ 247.55 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 247.55 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 256.51 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Nissan Versa Note 2 Doors
Compact

Nissan Versa Note 2 Doors

  • 4
  • 2
  • 2
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
1 supplier 2 deals
From US$ 250.06 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 250.06 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 259.02 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Buick Regal
Compact

Buick Regal

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
3 suppliers 6 deals
From US$ 277.08 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 277.08 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 286.04 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 580.21 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 589.17 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 581.12 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 590.08 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Toyota RAV4
Medium SUV

Toyota RAV4

  • 5
  • 2
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
1 supplier 2 deals
From US$ 303.90 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 303.90 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 313.90 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Chevrolet Spark
Economy

Chevrolet Spark

  • 4
  • 2
  • 2
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
3 suppliers 6 deals
From US$ 304.15 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 304.15 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 313.11 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 566.48 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 575.44 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 569.58 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 578.54 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Chevrolet Spark 4 Doors
Mini

Chevrolet Spark 4 Doors

  • 5
  • 1
  • 4
  • Auto
  • A/C
Bitcoin Payment Available
Bitcoin Payment Available
2 suppliers 4 deals
From US$ 304.15 total
Select Car
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 304.15 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 313.11 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal
Pick up:

JFK Airport

Drop off:

Indianapolis Airport

No Insurance

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

US$ 566.48 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal

Premier Protection

  • Full to Full

  • Free Cancellation

  • Collision Damage Waiver & TP

  • Third Party Liability Insurance

US$ 575.44 total
Bitcoin Payment Available
View deal